Instruments | Styles | Artists | Members | Forums |
      Subscribe Register Login 
Which recorder to buy first for someone with large hands? 
 

Which recorder to buy first for someone with large hands?

Search Forums: 
    
[-]
Which recorder to buy first for someone with large hands?    18:45 on Monday, June 29, 2009 Vote for this post Vote against this post 0 votes

bicycle
(17 points)

I've read that the alto or tenor should be the first choise.
was this bad advise? Has anyone had any experience with LMI recorders?

[-]
Re: Which recorder to buy first for someone with large hands?    22:22 on Saturday, July 04, 2009 Vote for this post Vote against this post 0 votes

bicycle
(17 points)

Being impatient, I ordered an Yamaha YRS-23 from out of state. It was not a large investment, (In fact, the shipping charges were more than the price f the instrument.)and I find it to be comfortable to hold.
Now to practice enough so I don't "squeek". I believe I'm in for a lot of fun.

[-]
Re: Which recorder to buy first for someone with large hands?    21:43 on Sunday, August 02, 2009 Vote for this post Vote against this post 0 votes

dancingcello
(60 points)

Hello, I've played all the recorder "voices" at one time or another and for "large hands" I think the tenor is the best one to learn initially. On the recorder, the easiest scale is that of the key note. On the tenor and soprano this scale is C major (no sharps or flats). On the alto, bass and sopranino the "key note scale" is F major (B flat).

My experience with working with children at least, is that for most beginners, scales with sharps or flats in their key signatures are confusing and/or intimidating. And somehow the C major scale just seems to be a "natural" place to start--especially if you ever played the piano. Since you need a larger instrument, the tenor recorder fits the bill.

To begin, I would recommend a nice resin Yamaha (http://www.amazon.com/Yamaha-3-Piece-C-Tenor-Recorder-Brown/dp/B0002EB5UI/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&s=musical-instruments&qid=1249266178&sr=1-2). I have several black ones which I keep around for family and friends so we can play together and they seem to be consistently easy to play right out of the case/box. They're not terribly sensitive to the weather/humidity--which is nice. The main drawback is that they don't absorb moisture and if you're playing for an extended period of time they can get pretty sloppy with spit.

I also have several wood tenors (maple, pear, rosewood) and the wood ones--especially if they're cheap--tend to be temperamental unless you play them consistently. Always try a wooden tenor out before you buy. See if you can play the key note (all holes covered) without too much difficulty. If you can't, more than likely it will be one of those temperamental types and as a first instrument, it could be discouraging. Also, be sure it comes with double holes for low D & D#; double keys for low C & C#. Even with large hands a tenor can be difficult to play if you don't have the double keys.

Hope that helps. Let me know how it goes.

<Added>

PS I see that you actually bought a Yamaha--didn't notice the post script. How are you doing? I would imagine you're past the "squeaky stage" by now. ;)

[-]
Re: Which recorder to buy first for someone with large hands?    18:33 on Monday, August 03, 2009 Vote for this post Vote against this post 0 votes

bicycle
(17 points)

Thank you.
"Impatient" Bike

   

This forum: Older: Are there comparable units to the yra 302B, 312B and 314B........
 Newer: Samir Recorder? Anyone familiar with this brand?

 




8notes in other languages:              


 
© 2000-2014 8notes.com