Re: Bob Dylan or Neil Young 09:40 on Friday, September 02, 2005
I agree Bob Dylan is the best lyricist ever - Call me a stuck up indie kid, but I lost respect for him for being in a Victorias Secret commercial.. how was it relevant to his music, or even to him? how are Victorias Secret and Bob Dylan connected? wheres the challenge for him? - When an artist does that, its called selling out, simple as that - While I still respect and love Bob Dylans music and will never stop listening to him, this causes me to say Neil Young is better. Even musically and lyrically, it was always too close to tell.
Re: Bob Dylan or Neil Young 16:53 on Saturday, September 03, 2005
Definitetly Bob Dylan I am half way through reading his auto biogphy. Neil Young is alright worth a listen but not a buy. My favs by Dylan are Tangled Up in Blue and Desolation Row. Just to add I dont think this shold be based on guitar skills I think it should be based on songwriting skills.
bob dylan! it has to be, the man wrote Hurricane for christs sake! although i dont deny that young is a great singer/songwriter i think it should be more a cases of dylan or cash, only after hearing the last four albulms he did though, the ones with rubin. Jack Johnson to be this generations dylan!