Snorkel Generally, it was good. I didn't find any tonal, rhythmic, or orchestrative mistakes. However, it did seem a little mechanical and bland. The fact that it was a midi file contributed to this observation, I'm sure, but I had a hard a time getting into it. I didn't quite feel it, but that has more to do with personal preferrence than orchestration or execution. Like I said, it was good, but the notes didn't jump out at me or wrestle with my feelings. I gave you 5 stars because I believe this piece was wrongly down rated from the beginning, making it appear unappealing to those who would otherwise take a listen.