|
|
 |
Quatch
(3 points)
| 
Hi,
I am total beginner at instrument play, I am 21, but I really feel need to start learning some instrument. I cannot decide between clarinet and trumpet. Please, can you help me to decide?
Which instrument is easier to play, easier to learn? Considering fingers, breath, timeconsumption... Which one do you think is more beautyful and which has greater usage?
I'll be very grateful for your posts.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
.JPG)
bbrandon
(41 points)
|
Well its a matter of opinion of which sound you like better. So my personal experience is that the clarinet is easier to learn than the trumpet...Each of them is a challenge though. I obviously play the trumpet and finally started loving it about 2 years ago when i learned beyond some barrier i guess and it was totally different. So if you are willing to put a good amount of time and effort into either, you will excel. I have heard that studies show that the trumpet is the most physical instrument out of them all by far. I would say that trumpet is harder but takes a lot of work and if u work it will pay off.
Hope this helps
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
jesusonguitar489
3
|
Don't mind me, I'm just trying to rack up some points. While I'm here though, pick neither. Try guitar.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
jesusonguitar489
3
|
My keyboard was messed up tha day, sorry. But really guitar is way better for the following reasons:
1.) You don't have to breath in to it. With a guitar, you can keep playing without the need of breathing.
2.) You can sing and play it at the same time. Because you have to breath into the trumpet(or clarinet), you can't sing.
3.) If it's finger strain you're worried about, you can buy light strings, which don't cause much force.
Believe me, I play the saxophone, and it's cool and all. But the guitar is way better.
Between trumpet and clarinet, though, trumpet sounds better and the mouth piece doesn't break.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
CP124
(34 points)
|
I agree with Brandon both instruments have their challenges trumpet you have less fingers to learn however one key can equal five. But clairnet requires less physical ability but I personally love trumpet a lot more because it's so much more diverse you can play latin, jazz, classical, blues etc. you can do the same with clairnet too, but it's not as commonly seen or no. So it depends on your personal tastes too. Trumpet does take much more time to learn and develop technique.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
iloveclarinet
(8 points)
|
My personal opinion, i think all woodwind instruments are so much easier to learn just because one fingering equals one note and you don't have to worry about buzzing the right pitch. do what you want, but i think clarinet as easier, but then again that is from a clarinet player's point of view.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
suzie
(255 points)
|
I think that, in a way, brass instruments are more costly in the long run vs clarinet for example. Brass instruments have the possibilities of red-rot and costly s-brace or dent/buckle repairs whereas the most common thing to happen with clarinet (aside from needing a new reed) would be needing a new pad to be replaced which may cost you about $10. I think that, overall, clarinets are cheaper too and a majority of brass instruments (trumpets, especially) are clear or gold lacquered which tends to wear, chip, and flake off whereas most clarinet plated finishes last longer. With clarinet, you can put say a Selmer C* mouthpiece w/ a #2 Vandoren reed and hit every note throughout the clarinet's range but with trumpet, depending on your practice time, etc., you may have to spend about $25+ on a new mouthpiece to progress to the higher notes vs getting a harder $3 reed.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
clarinet37
(1 point)
|
i don't know much about trumpet but clarinet is certainly not cheap or easy. a beginner instrument can be purchased for a few hundred dollars but to get a truly rich tone a professional instrument is necessary and that can cost anywhere from $2500 up. a mouthpiece can also be quite pricy (much more than $25) and reeds really add up. cheap reeds are good for beginners but with any air support a better reed is needed and they cost generally around $3 each. the number of reeds used a year is enormous. as for difficulty, clarinet is not hard to play but it is hard to play well. it takes serious concentration and practice to be able to play the fingerings, tongue clearly, have a dark tone, play with expression, and just play well overall. still, clarinet is amazing and so much fun. it is definately worth the time and money. playing it in an ensemble is magical.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
suzie
(255 points)
|
A wooden Buffet E11 (or equivalent) is not a necessity to start playing the clarinet on. Beginning clarinets sell in good playing condition and good cosmetic condition for $100 and under. I know this due to the fact that I've bought and sold clarinets over the past few years and that's the average price range for a student model. Intermediate models range higher depending on the brand and model you purchase as you can purchase a wooden Selmer Signet for less than $150 in great playing condition and a wooden Buffet E11 wooden clarinet in great condition for less than $500. Many times a decent mouthpiece will come with your clarinet that you purchase so you wouldn't need to invest further in another mouthpiece for a while. I agree that reeds cost around $3 ea. however purchasing individually once one breaks is a waste of $. A box of 10 Bb clarinet reeds by Vandoren is less than $18 via wwbw.com which equals out to $1.80 ea. which is almost 1/2 the cost of getting a reed from your local store. A lot of the cost differences between instruments depends on where you buy which is why it's important to cross your t's and dot your i's before purchasing musical instruments.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
ClarinetClaire
(40 points)
|
Both instruments are quite beautiful. But, the clarinet is easier and quieter in case you live next door to people. The trumpet makes your lips all chapped and swollen.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
highC
(7 points)
|
I've been playin the trumpet for years and I love it. With the right amount of pracice weekly, your talent will improve and I can almost guarantee you will fall in love with this instrument. Any instrument starts off challening but there are few instruments that can produce a sound more lovely and pure than the trumpet.
After playing for a while, your lips will get tired but they won't get swollen
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
WoodwindkicksBra
ss
|
i like both a lot, but i would play clarinet. it's got a beautiful sound if you play it right and, woodwinds kick brass! 
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
koolkat12296
(34 points)
|
Ok, this is just my opinion but i would do trumpet because it's very uppy and exciting! You could even eventually get into a jazz band if you wanted with trumpet. You have some great opporitunities with trumpet. But i guess clarinet is ok too. Hope i helped!
|
|
|
|
|
searching...
