My favorite musical is Moulin Rouge

Sweeney Todd--and no, I don't plan to see the movie version.

My favorite musical is Moulin Rouge

Wait! speaking of movies isn't this one--and thus not a musical?

Scotch, as I understand it, a musical is a movie where the characters have a propensity to break into song at a moment's notice. Sometimes, it's full song and dance routines (in the middle of a farmyard or whatever). So, Moulin Rouge, being full of arbitrary singing, is indeed a musical.

Clearly, you don't "understand it".

I don't know what your definition of a "musical" is, but I believe one that includes films is perfectly valid. Particularly so since the original poster cited a film as their favourite musical.

I LOVE Marry Popins!!

My favorite Broadway musical would be Phantom of the Opera. Partially because that's the only musical I've seen on Broadway. lol Actually come to think of it, I did also see Les Miserables...

I've never seen anything on Broadway. I hope to sometime in the furture. My computer teacher said if Wicked came to Chicago, then we could have a party in computer class and go see it.

Les Miserables...

either "The Wall" or "The Phantom of the Opera"

My Favorite haas to be Kiss Me Kate, because that is where I met my wife.

My second favorite is Don Pasquale, because the Horn part has you go through every transposition there is.

mine would be Les Miserables. and perhaps Miss Saigon.

Im torn between Chicago and Rent.

Rent! But I do really like Phantom of the Opera, as well as the Sound of Music.