Whose Pink Floyd most creative member

Whose Pink Floyd most creative member 06:10 on Sunday, July 2, 2006

Hello there....I was just wondering what peoples opinions are of the most creative writer in Pink Floyd...Whether it be "Mad Cap" Syd Barret, Rogers Waters or David Gilmour...

Me well i have a soft spot for barret and waters but dont have a favourite...Id like to know who other people think???????????

Re: Whose Pink Floyd most creative member 21:13 on Sunday, July 2, 2006

muso_man
(80 points)

Posted by muso_man

hmm well to each his own...which albums by david gilmour do you like?

Re: Whose Pink Floyd most creative member 03:35 on Tuesday, July 4, 2006

rushisqueer
(161 points)

Posted by rushisqueer

nah Roger Waters is more vreative than David Gilmour. Waters was probably the greatest lyricist ever aside from Bob Dylan.

Re: Whose Pink Floyd most creative member 05:37 on Tuesday, July 4, 2006

muso_man
(80 points)

Posted by muso_man

Aha waters is one of the best lyricist but syd barret had some pretty crazy albums that were pretty mad...but the meaning behind the words in waters songs was unreal

Re: Whose Pink Floyd most creative member 08:55 on Tuesday, July 4, 2006

lozzyjay
(2 points)

Posted by lozzyjay

roger waters, no doubt about it! I love him so much. And I just saw him in concert on saturday and he was AWESOME!!

This forum:	Older: yeah yeah yeahs,franz ferdinand,gnarls barkley remixes up now
	Newer: Rock Classic